Last month, I opened my SEO dashboard expecting a little pat on the back. Rankings were up. My pages were sitting nicely on page one. But the traffic? Flatlined. For a second, I thought GA4 was having one of its existential crises again.

But no — the problem wasn’t the data. The problem was the search engine itself.

Google is quietly — or not so quietly — transforming its search experience with Gemini AI and a new feature called AI Overviews.

If you haven’t seen it yet, it’s like a featured snippet on steroids. It answers the user’s question directly at the top of the page… often using content from your website… without sending any traffic your way.

Classic, right?

This isn’t just another algorithm update. It’s a fundamental shift in how search works — and if you rely on SEO to bring in leads, eyeballs, or conversions, you need to understand what’s happening. Fast.

What’s actually changing

First, let’s get clear on the jargon.

Gemini is Google’s next-gen AI model — the one they’re betting the farm on to compete with OpenAI. It’s already powering Bard (now rebranded as Gemini), and it’s being injected into Google Search through something called AI Overviews.

If you’ve searched for something like “how to clean a cast iron skillet” recently, there’s a good chance Google answered you before you even looked at the links. That’s an AI Overview.

It looks like a neat little summary box at the top of the page, complete with key steps, product suggestions, sometimes even bullet points pulled from random sites (maybe yours). It’s Google’s AI stitching together answers, so you don’t have to click around.

Convenient? Yes.
Good for SEO-driven traffic? Not so much.

It often uses your content to generate the answer, cites you somewhere, but gives the user no real reason to visit your site unless they scroll past the entire summary (which fewer people are doing).

It’s not live in every country or for every query — yet. But Google’s rolling it out fast. And spoiler: it’s only going to get more common, especially for how-to queries, product comparisons, and health-related content.

For Marketers and SEO

The problem is… your content might rank — and still not get clicked.

Because in this new AI-powered landscape, visibility ≠ traffic anymore: 

  • Organic links are getting pushed further down the page. Even position #1 doesn’t feel like #1 when the AI block takes up half the screen.
  • Users get the answer instantly. No click. No engagement. No conversion funnel. Just… thanks, goodbye.
  • You’re feeding the machine. If you’ve created helpful, structured content (which you should), Google may reward you by… quoting you in a box that skips your site entirely.
  • Attribution is weak. Sometimes you’re credited. Sometimes you’re not. Sometimes your brand name is there. Sometimes it’s just your favicon — if you’re lucky.

For marketers, this means rethinking what SEO success looks like. Rankings alone aren’t enough. You need to measure how your brand appears, whether you’re cited, and how to build trust at the first glance — even if there’s no click.

Because in the age of AI search, your brand is showing up. 

But is it showing up well enough to be remembered?

So… What now? 

This new search experience isn’t a glitch. It’s the future Google is building — and it’s not asking for permission.

But here’s the good news: you’re not powerless. While AI Overviews are stealing the spotlight (and your clicks), smart marketers can adapt. The playbook is changing — but it’s not blank.

Here’s what you can (and should) do right now to stay visible, useful, and ahead of the curve:

1. Structure your content for the machine

Yes, write for humans. But also format your content like it’s going to be digested by a robot — because it is.

  • Use clear headers (H2, H3) that map to real questions.
  • Break answers down into bullet points, numbered steps, short paragraphs.
  • Implement FAQ sections at the bottom of your content. Google loves them.
  • Use schema markup (FAQ, How-To, Product, Organization). It helps the AI understand and prioritize your info.

Google is essentially looking for content it can repurpose easily. If you’re chaotic, verbose, or vague, you’ll be skipped — even if your content is technically better.

2. Give short answers, then go deep

Here’s the trick: summarize your answer in 1-2 lines at the top of the page, then develop it in detail.

Think of it like this: you’re feeding the AI a bite-sized quote, while giving real readers a reason to scroll further. The AI gets its summary. The human gets the full meal. Win-win.

3. Double down on brand visibility, not just clicks

Your brand showing up in the AI Overview — even without a click — is still a visibility win. But only if:

  • Your brand name is clearly visible.
  • Your favicon/logo is memorable.
  • You’re cited more than once (consistency builds authority).
  • The content tone and structure match your voice.

In this new game, brand is your moat. If users remember you from AI summaries and come back to search for you directly, you’ve won the long game.

4. Build trust signals everywhere

Google’s AI is getting smarter at identifying “trusted” sources. So you need to look and behave like one:

  • Include expert authorship or editorial guidelines.
  • Get real backlinks from credible domains (yes, they still matter — a bit).
  • Keep your content updated, especially for YMYL topics (Your Money, Your Life).

And let’s not forget: user behavior feeds the AI. If people click your link, bounce in two seconds, or never return… that’s a red flag.

5. Think beyond Google

While everyone’s panicking about Google, there’s another player stealing clicks: ChatGPT + Bing.

More users (especially in tech, B2B, and education) are starting their research inside ChatGPT. And guess where ChatGPT gets a lot of its info from? Bing’s index — which is built on structured, trusted websites.

Translation? Bing SEO is having a quiet comeback. Submit your sitemap. Optimize your title tags. Track your Bing traffic. It’s low effort — and right now, low competition.

6. Stop measuring success like it’s 2018

If you’re still reporting on “organic traffic” without context, you’re missing the plot.

Here’s what to look at instead:

  • SERP presence (are you cited in AI Overviews, snippets, FAQs?): can be seen directly from the Position Tracking tool (in Semrush). 
  • Branded search volume (are more people searching you, not just topics?)
  • Time on site & return visits (are users who land on your site actually staying and coming back?)
  • Mentions and backlinks from credible sources (AI loves authority)

In short: focus less on raw traffic, and more on perceived expertise and brand memory. The kind of stuff that doesn’t vanish when the AI box moves the goalposts.

We’ve seen SEO change before. Mobile-first, RankBrain, BERT, Core Web Vitals — we adapted. This is just a bigger leap.

But here’s the mindset shift: you’re no longer optimizing just for search engines. You’re optimizing for search engines run by AI.
That means faster answers, fewer clicks, more competition, and a higher bar for trust.

If your content is clear, helpful, structured, and backed by a visible brand — you’ll stay in the game. If not, the AI won’t even notice you.

And neither will your audience.

Categorized in:

Trends & Innovation